The decision to use that maximum ultimately belongs to the instructor.

An airline pilot operates under company procedures, federal regulations, aircraft limitations, checklists, and weather minimums. But once that pilot is responsible for a flight, the ultimate decision still rests in the cockpit. If the pilot does not believe it is safe to fly, the plane does not leave the ground.
Dive instruction is not so different.
One cannot scroll through industry social media right now without seeing opinions about the recent accidents our industry has suffered. As is often the case after a tragedy, many armchair experts quickly weigh in on what is supposedly “wrong” with training standards, instructor ratios, agencies, risk management, and the way we teach people to dive.
But before we rush to blame “lax standards,” we need to remember what a standard actually is. Training agencies establish maximum ratios, minimum requirements, required skills, supervision expectations, and course performance standards. Those standards create the agreed-upon boundaries for instruction. But no agency requires an instructor to teach at the maximum ratio. A maximum is not a mandate. It is a ceiling.
The decision to use that maximum ultimately belongs to the instructor. Should conditions, student ability, visibility, current, temperature, task loading, site logistics, or available support staff warrant a smaller group, it is the instructor’s responsibility to make that call. Like the pilot in command, the instructor must decide whether the planned training is appropriate for the conditions in front of them.
Paid Advertisement
When I first started teaching, I was working in Table Rock Lake near Branson, Missouri. Like many inland locations in the Midwest, summer visibility could be extremely poor due to warm-water algae blooms. There were days when visibility was only three to five feet. In those conditions, without additional divemaster support, one instructor would be challenged to safely supervise a maximum-sized class while still meeting direct supervision requirements for teaching and evaluation.
There was nothing in the standards that prevented me from being more conservative. I could divide the class into smaller groups, take two students at a time for open water work. Did it make the day longer for everyone involved? Absolutely. But safety was not compromised.
A ratio that may be reasonable in clear, calm, shallow water with experienced assistants may be completely inappropriate in cold, dark, low-visibility water with nervous students and no support staff.
Standards define what is permitted. Professionalism determines what is prudent.
So before we blame training agencies or assume the answer is always more regulation, we need to look inward as an industry. The responsibility to manage class size, site conditions, student readiness, and instructional support rests with us. The agencies may provide the procedures, limits, and checklists. But once the class enters the water, the instructor is the one in command.
Paid Advertisement
Click here to read this article on our Flippingbook platform.
More from This Issue:
THIS MONTH’S ADVERTISING PARTNERS
RECENT ISSUES
MAGAZINE TOPICS